Monday, October 13, 2014

Essay Questions for Ancient Sunlight

Midterm Questions: You have to write on one of the following questions. This should be 6-12 pages long, double-spaced. The challenge with this paper is to include some of the tons of information you have at your fingertips, while not just writing an information regurgitation paper. In fact, the majority of the paper should be you making an argument that harnesses the information. Cite properly.

 I.

In the section “How Can Things Look So Good Yet Be So Bad,” Hartmann uses two metaphors to describe why we don’t always perceive the world’s critical condition: “There are two ways that things can look fine even when an entire civilization is headed for trouble.  1. Don’t ‘pay as you go’ – just live off your ‘startup capital’ … 2. The ‘Ponzi scheme’ … Is the world run like a Ponzia scheme, or like the hopeful software company?” (20-23).
First, analyze what Hartmann is saying in his two metaphors.  Then synthesize the research you have conducted on your own topic with the knowledge you have gathered from the presentations, and apply Hartmann’s metaphors to 4 or 5 of the topics you learned about during the presentations. What, according to your research, or Hartmann’s arguments can we do to overcome the “startup capital” or “Ponzi” mentality; be specific.  Be sure to refer to other moments in TLHAS to support your claims. Make sure you have a clear thesis.


II.

Hartmann constantly remarks that “our problem is rooted in our worldview.”  In the final chapter of the book, Hartmann argues for three solutions that will solve “our problem:”
1. History demonstrates that the deepest and most meaningful cultural/social/political changes began with individuals, not organizations, governments, or institutions.  2. In helping to “save the world,” the most important work you and I face is to help individuals transform their ability to perceive reality and control the stories they believe … 3. Then, out of this new perspective, we ourselves will come up with the solutions in ways that you and I right now probably can’t even imagine. (352-353)
First, examine Hartmann’s assertion that “our worldview” is the cause of our problems.  Then, using your research as well as what you learned from the presentations, assess the validity of Hartmann’s three claims by identifying and arguing for or against solutions for 4 or 5 topics you learned about during the presentations.  Be sure to refer to other moments in TLHAS to support your claims.  Make sure you have a clear thesis.

No comments:

Post a Comment